Skip to main content

And this is a little disturbing

Considering how much weight-loss advice is out there, and has been out there, the fact that "researchers" are "debunking" several weight-loss "myths" is no big surprise. Nothing new. Weight-loss advice is tossed about like a Frisbee in spring. We try it, it works or it doesn't, we try something else. Eventually we find (or, sometimes, we don't) a manageable plan that fits with our lifestyle and helps us achieve our goals.

I'm still looking. Heh.

I don't watch the news, but my husband mentioned that NBC has been airing some little weight-loss tidbits this week. So I went looking for some snippets and here's one I found, from the esteemed New England Journal of Medicine.

The problem with articles like this is that they tell you what doesn't work, without suggesting what does. This one is different. Dr. David Allison of the University of Alabama at Birmingham led the study and concluded:
So what does work? Drugs do, to an extent, says Allison, a biostatician. “For people who are very obese, pharmaceuticals work a little bit,” he said. So does surgery to make the stomach smaller. The companies that make the devices used for the surgery, and the surgical centers, are doing the randomized, controlled clinical trials that can prove whether something works, Allison says. “Clearly, these are things we should be investing in,” he said.
I'm no weight-loss expert (I would call myself knowledgeable, having been studying and practicing for 50 years now), but any journal article that suggests we need to be "investing" in drugs and surgical techniques smacks of some kind of self-serving agenda.

I will certainly acknowledge that bariatric surgery can make a miraculous difference in the lives of the severely obese. I'm not so sure about drugs. Weight-loss pills are constantly tested, some are approved and are then summarily withdrawn due to side effects like, oh, heart damage or death.

There was no real advice dispensed in the journal article. It was simply a study saying that while such-and-such has been touted as a way to drop pounds, it's never been proven. UAB-Birmingham has vowed to do a clinical trial on the breakfast myth. Does eating breakfast help you lose weight? Does skipping it make you fatter? Or does it make a difference at all?

For what it's worth, my husband rarely eats breakfast. And has a BMI of 23.6. I rarely skip breakfast and my BMI is mumble-mumble-mumble. So there's that. HOWEVER, skipping breakfast is not an option for me. I've adopted the idea that, while I may lose weight more slowly or not at all, I'm a nicer person if my blood sugar levels stay somewhat steady throughout the day.

It's not all about the pounds. For me, anyway, it has to be about something I can manage.

Comments

Diandra said…
When comparing all studies done, it seems that most approaches to weight loss work - as long as you eat less calories than you need. But no matter whether you do low-carb or low-protein or low-fat, all participants who stick to the rules seem to lose at similar speed. It seems as if in the end for healthy people it is pretty simple. Eat less, work out more. (But I know how that is not much fun and pretty frustrating at times.)
Debbi McNeer said…
Also, suggesting the eat-less/move-more approach isn't especially profitable for companies who make drugs or surgical supplies. Just sayin'.

Popular posts from this blog

YES!

Update on the water: the circuit breaker tripped, either due to a power surge when the electricity came back on last night OR when lightning struck in the area. My neighbor's electric fence control box got hit in the same area. He was able to reset the circuit breaker for us and we have WATER! I think I'll go do a load of laundry. Heh.

And the winner is …

Kitten with a Whiplash, who left two comments and it was the second (which had nothing to do with the contest) which won the prize. Congratulations, and since the Kitten was the only commenter who expressed any interest in actually winning it, I'm so glad the Universe took care of it. Heh.

What a weekend! But first, how was yours? I hope you did some fun stuff and got some necessary stuff done, as well. It's all about balance.

Saturday was our fun day (but we had to drive, drive, drive to get there and then drive, drive, drive home again, all in one day, boy was I tired). We went to my husband's granddaughter's first birthday party. In addition to a sweet little doll, suitable for ages 0+ (meaning it has no parts that will come loose, and do you know how difficult it is to find dolls for babies when you live in the Middle of Nowhere?), I made her this:


I haven't sewn anything in a month of Sundays, so was a little apprehensive about finishing it on time, but this p…

It's all about the food

The dieting portion of this blog is temporarily suspended. Continue reading at your own risk.

If you’re going to throw a party, be sure to have good food and plenty of it. That’s my daughter’s philosophy, and I think it’s pretty good advice.

The members of the group who will be here Thursday night are middle-aged and older, so I think mostly traditional appetizers are in order. We’ll have Swedish meatballs and those little sausages cooked in a sweet-and-sour sauce, along with artichoke dip, hummus with vegetables and crackers, a bowl of cinnamon-spiced nuts and a fruit pizza.

Cupcakes are on the menu. Cupcakes sure seem to be popular these days – Google Blogsearch came up with 1,181,447 hits and amazon.com is selling a boatload of cupcake cookbooks.

Mine are plain old chocolate, and will be decorated with the words “Yes We Can” on top. I think some will be iced in blue and some in white, with red lettering.

I’m also making pig candy. I first had this at one of my daughter’s Oscar parties s…