Homemade peanut butter. Throw some peanuts into your blender and let the magic happen. Don't stop too soon. There's a point, a few minutes into the process, where it stops sounding like chopped peanuts. Keep going for a couple more minutes. If you like crunchy peanut butter, chop a handful of nuts separately and stir into the smooth mixture. This isn't as creamy as Jif, and it isn't as sweet, either, since the only ingredient is PEANUTS.